how mergers impact a firm’s retirement plan

plus how to handle partners who want to opt out.

older businessman sitting at desk smiling as wall clock indicates 5 minutes to retirementby marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

how do mergers impact a firm’s partner retirement plan?

more on buyouts: why 30% of cpa firm retirement plans are defective | are partner buyout plans just ponzi schemes? | clawback and how to handle it | can partners compete after they leave? | disability is far more complex than death | mandatory retirement? 4 reasons the firm comes first | how to transition clients from retiring partners | vesting can cover part-timers, too | eat what you kill? then maybe ‘book of business’ is for you | the multiple of compensation method, fully explained | 5 points to consider when paying out goodwill | how to set terms and limits for goodwill payouts | 4 ways to decide how to pay out capital

these suggestions propose verbiage that could be included in the firm’s partner agreement: read more →

what competence really means for partners

martin bissett
bissett

bonus: four outlooks from our exclusive expert council: baker, dobek, tierney, mister.

by martin bissett
passport to partnership

the skill in producing financial reports is limited by the quality of the information presented to the cpa by the client. motivation of the client to influence that financial information comes in many forms, some intentional and some unintentional. competence comes first in being able to resist pressure and present a true and accurate position of the client’s organization.

learn more
learn more

sounds obvious, doesn’t it? but there’s a twist.

more on the passport to partnership: sailing through the seven c’s to partnership | passport to partnership: new research shows wide gap between partners and partners-to-be

competence didn’t actually rank highly in the majority of partner requirements when interviewed in our study at all.

read more →

why 30% of cpa firm retirement plans are fatally flawed

senior businessman holding briefcasemake provisions, or state partnership laws may do it for you.

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

twenty to thirty percent of all accounting firm partnership agreements have no provision for goodwill-based retirement payments to partners departing due to death, disability, retirement or withdrawal.

more on retirement: the top 10 mistakes in partner retirement plans | 20 new, essential keys for today’s partner retirement plans | you want goodwill payments? give proper retirement notice | compromise is in order for some goodwill payouts | three ways to calculate goodwill payable in partner buyouts, none of them great | the ins and outs of aav for goodwill | 5 points to consider when paying out goodwill | how to set terms and limits for goodwill payouts

they’re in for a rude surprise. read more →

sailing through the seven c’s to partnership

martin bissett
bissett

competence comes first. but it’s only a prerequisite.

bonus worksheets: 11 questions to plan your path to partnership

by martin bissett
passport to partnership

staffers aspiring to be partners must learn the key characteristics of successful partners. they also must learn how to develop their own personal plans to achieve partnership. firms and staffers alike need a clear set of procedures, processes and milestones for turning top talent into the next generation of firm leadership.

there are seven critically important criteria by which partners assess partners-to-be. i call them:

the seven c’s read more →

passport to partnership: new research shows wide gap between partners and partners-to-be

martin bissett
bissett

what we have here is a failure to communicate.

editor’s note: with this article, 卡塔尔世界杯常规比赛时间 introduces a new series of articles by martin bissett reporting on the findings of his proprietary research into the keys to making partner. the research is based on hundreds of interviews with partners and practitioners at more than 30 firms in the u.s. and the u.k., dozens of experts and advisors, and his own 20 years of experience in the field. in his research, bissett uncovered a wide gap between what partners say they seek in a staffer yearning to be partner and what they actually do and say to train and nurture the staffer. his work in passport to partnership is dedicated to bridging that gap, revealing to both partners and partners-to-be the unspoken rules, and working to create a bulletproof program to guide their efforts.

by martin bissett
passport to partnership

learn more
learn more

have you ever wondered what the partners of your firm are looking for from you, beyond your technical abilities?

for full disclosure, i am not an accountant, but i have spent decades working with accounting firms of all shapes and sizes in the united kingdom, the united states and europe.

more from martin bissett:  selling on value vs. fees | 3 ways to convert scheduling practices to new fees | selling vs. attracting to build relationships | when selling, don’t chase new fees, attract them | selling accounting services doesn’t have to be hard! | ‘selling’ isn’t a dirty word | 8 factors in practice development success | in sales, perception is reality | success begins with accountability | do you realize you’re failing? | winning your first client

i noticed over time that in many firms, partners may often regard one or more of their managers as not being “partner material” because they feel that the manager does not exhibit the traits they are looking for.

read more →

the top 10 mistakes in partner retirement plans

top 10 signis your firm guilty of any of these?

by marc rosenberg

mistakes abound in partner retirement plans. here are the top 10 we see:

more on retirement: are partner buyout plans just ponzi schemes? | 20 new, essential keys for today’s partner retirement plans | clawback and how to handle it | can partners compete after they leave? | how to juggle tax considerations for partner retirement benefits | retirement plan funding? what funding? | vesting can cover part-timers, too

read more →

are partner buyout plans just ponzi schemes?

businessman tightly holding briefcase with dollar sign on itapply this test to your firm’s succession plan.

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

most multi-partner cpa firms have partner buyout plans that enable partners who leave the firm via retirement, death, disability or withdrawal to redeem their share of the firm’s value.

more on buyouts: 20 new, essential keys for today’s partner retirement plans | clawback and how to handle it | can partners compete after they leave? | retirement plan funding? what funding? | why you’ll get less from your partners in a buyout than you might by selling the whole firm | partners may balk at guaranteeing retirement obligations

over the last 10-20 years, retirement plans have come under more scrutiny as younger partners question whether departing partners are worth the payments due them and whether the firm can afford those payments. staff with near-term partner potential also question whether to commit themselves to making these payments. both of these groups fear that the firm will not be able to survive the retirement of dynamic, rainmaking partners who have tight relationships with their clients.

read more →

20 new, essential keys for today’s partner retirement plans

contract concept - conceptual close up of eyeglasses and ballpoint pen on top of partnership agreement paper placed on white table.

a lot is changing fast. here’s what your partner agreement needs today.

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

let’s take a moment to simply summarize the many critical aspects of a well written partner retirement/buyout plan.

at first glance, those unfamiliar with how a proper plan should be written may find the 20-plus key provisions listed below to be daunting. but i would caution against such thinking.  in my 20 years of consulting to cpa firms in this area, i have been asked to resolve messy disputes regarding every item listed below.

more on retirement: clawback and how to handle it | can partners compete after they leave? | disability is far more complex than death | even partner agreements must face death | 6 ways to leave a cpa firm (retirement’s just 1) | how to juggle tax considerations for partner retirement benefits | two ways to retire, and one’s not pretty | how to transition clients from retiring partners | compromise is in order for some goodwill payouts | why you’ll get less from your partners in a buyout than you might by selling the whole firm | the multiple of compensation method, fully explained

read more →

clawback and how to handle it

bear paw with clawsbear paw with clawsfive-year adjustments may ease partners’ minds.

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

some firms struggle to agree on the details of a partner retirement plan.

more on retirement: can partners compete after they leave? | disability is far more complex than death | how to juggle tax considerations for partner retirement benefits | mandatory retirement? 4 reasons the firm comes first | you want goodwill payments? give proper retirement notice | vesting can cover part-timers, too | why you’ll get less from your partners in a buyout than you might by selling the whole firm | the multiple of compensation method, fully explained

one of the biggest items of contention is the valuation of their goodwill for internal retirement purposes. in these cases, the partners are anxious about obligating themselves to pay huge buyout benefits.

read more →

can partners compete after they leave? maybe.

businessman with fingers crossed behind backbonus: sample non-solicitation agreement.

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

a non-compete covenant prohibits departed partners from joining another cpa firm or creating their own firm within a radius of a specified number of miles from the firm, within a specified period of time after their departure.

increasingly, firms are writing and enforcing tougher and tighter non-compete clauses.

one of the key tests that courts have used in ruling on the enforceability of non-compete agreements (different from non-solicitation) is the extent to which such agreements prevent the departing partner from earning a living.

more on retirement: disability is far more complex than death | 6 ways to leave a cpa firm (retirement’s just 1) | how to juggle tax considerations for partner retirement benefits | mandatory retirement? 4 reasons the firm comes first | how to transition clients from retiring partners | retirement plan funding? what funding? | when retiring partners take a specialty with them | clients leaving? time to reduce retirement benefits | partners may balk at guaranteeing retirement obligations

the vast majority of u.s firms are local practices located in areas with many competing firms. if a partner leaves to join another firm and does not attempt to take clients, it is very difficult to claim that the departing partner will substantially and irreparably damage the interests and the value of the firm.

read more →

partner disability: worse than death?

mature male patient playing a mobile on bed in hospital.the willingness to return to work may outstrip ability – then what?

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

you’ve probably heard the saying “disability is worse than death.” the point is that both death and disability are horrendous, catastrophic events.

more on buyouts: even partner agreements must face death | 6 ways to leave a cpa firm (retirement’s just 1) | how to juggle tax considerations for partner retirement benefits | two ways to retire, and one’s not pretty | mandatory retirement varies by firm size | mandatory retirement? 4 reasons the firm comes first | how to transition clients from retiring partners | you want goodwill payments? give proper retirement notice | retirement plan funding? what funding? | retirement vesting: the devil’s in the details | compromise is in order for some goodwill payouts

but the handling of issues related to death – for all parties concerned – are more straightforward, both personally and financially, than in the case of a disability. read more →

even partner agreements must face death

businessman shaking hands with grim reaper5 life insurance questions you should consider.

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

issues related to the death of a partner should be addressed in the firm’s partner agreement. consider the following:

  1. does the firm wish to accelerate vesting in any manner? does the firm wish to accelerate the payment frequency, vesting or both? partners are often tempted to be generous out of sympathy for the deceased partner’s family. what stops them from acting on this generosity impulse is the cold reality of how expensive this is. as a result, most firms treat death the same as an ordinary retirement.
  2. what must be done to assign the deceased partner’s clients to other firm members and to retain the clients?
  3. to what extent does the firm want to purchase life insurance on the lives of some or all of the partners? if they opt to purchase the insurance:

more on retirement: 6 ways to leave a cpa firm (retirement’s just 1) | how to juggle tax considerations for partner retirement benefits | two ways to retire, and one’s not pretty | mandatory retirement? 4 reasons the firm comes first | how to transition clients from retiring partners | retirement vesting: the devil’s in the details | eat what you kill? then maybe ‘book of business’ is for you

read more →

6 ways to leave a cpa firm (retirement’s just 1)

businessman sitting at laptopgoodwill depends on the method of departure.

by marc rosenberg
retirements & buyouts

in the literal sense, retirement is only one of six ways that partners may separate from their firm.

more on retirement: how to juggle tax considerations for partner retirement benefits | how to transition clients from retiring partners | you want goodwill payments? give proper retirement notice | retirement vesting: the devil’s in the details | compromise is in order for some goodwill payouts | three ways to calculate goodwill payable in partner buyouts, none of them great | 5 points to consider when paying out goodwill | how to set terms and limits for goodwill payouts | 4 ways to decide how to pay out capital | partners may balk at guaranteeing retirement obligations

benefits to partners are handled differently depending on which of the six ways they leave:
read more →